In my career, I’ve always felt like an interloper.
While I’ve been in digital marketing for nearly 20 years, the secret I hold is that I don’t see much difference between PR, communications and marketing. Sure, the tactics can be different, but the goals and psychology are the same.
In this article, we'll cover:
- Why consensus matters more than any single backlink
- Why “paid” isn’t a cover-all term for media
- Why PR and marketing should share one website, one message, one calendar and one scorecard
- How to measure success when clicks don’t tell the whole story
I’ve gone through my professional life looking at every business initiative, product launch and content campaign without the constraints of being in one department or the other. I’ve always been both.
Thankfully, it feels like the industry has finally caught up to the double life I’ve been living, all thanks to the shake-up that generative search and AI-influenced algorithms have caused. The lines between PR and marketing are blurrier than ever before, and communicators who have been working holistically are best set up to move fast and see results.
And the result we’re all now working so hard to achieve? Citations in generative search and LLM conversations.
Here are eight reasons why separating PR and marketing is a losing battle: to get seen and cited, the two teams need to work together.
1. Stop chasing a link. Chase consensus.
The goal is no longer to get one big backlink and watch the traffic (and sales) roll in. Now, communicators need to build a consistent brand narrative that fuels a consensus — a widespread understanding that feeds generative search the message you want told.
2. You can’t buy a citation, but you can buy the reach that earns one.
If you’re working with a vendor or agency that promises you can buy a citation, be wary. However, this is where the intersection of paid and earned comes into play. Generative search largely favors credible third-party sources. Putting spend behind your earned media pickups, whether through syndication, press releases or otherwise, will grow your reach. This reach will continue to influence the story that AI learns about your brand.
3. Don’t lump all paid together. Count sponsored content as third-party credibility.
In this new view of media, “paid” isn’t a one-size-fits-all term anymore. An ad can mean a Google or Meta advertising campaign, a native ad widget or a CTV spot, but it can also include syndicated content built for scale and reach. High-quality sponsored content is a real, human-written story on a third-party publisher’s site. Lumping these editorial stories together with traditional advertising formats can hinder your opportunity to place strong brand messaging on credible sites, all of which lead to your online consensus.
[Read More: Does Sponsored Content Help Brand Visibility in Generative Search? What AI Actually Evaluates]
4. PR and marketing must plan together for generative search visibility.
Generative search doesn’t care which department a story came from. It reads coverage, owned website content and structure, social media, and sponsored stories alike. Teams that plan paid and earned together, instead of handing work off between departments, can move faster and show up in more places. Factors to consider:
- Brand website: schema, structure, content, even agents and bots affect both teams
- Messaging alignment: are both teams using the language of your audience?
- Shared metrics: visibility rates, search traffic from AI chatbots, citations and mentions
- One calendar: your entire media mix, the PESO Model® we all know and love, should work together, not separately
5. A breadth of media placements helps your visibility, not just the big national hit.
We all know and love that feeling of getting a huge placement. You got your expert an interview in Forbes, a writeup in Wired, a guest spot on Call Her Daddy… what a dream. However, visibility comes from local and niche outlets, too, not just the national headlines. A large variety of placements in super-targeted, niche publications, even if smaller, will help build your story more broadly.
6. You might not be the expert on your optimal brand language.
Marketing teams love to write a bible for a brand — very specific language that tells the brand’s story and how it relates to audiences. Rounds and rounds of approvals and meetings and edits all funnel into a perfectly crafted positioning deck.
Generative search can blow that all up.
Be ready to change that story based on how your audience is actually looking for information online — more conversational queries with personalized follow-up questions. Study this and adapt the language you use in content, sales calls, event appearances and press releases accordingly.
[Read More: 5 Steps to Optimize Your Branded Content for Maximum AI Visibility]
7. Agile teams win every time.
Marketing and PR professionals thrive on nimbleness. I know this from experience — it’s chaotic, but it’s part of the fun. Right now, changes and updates are moving faster than ever. Remember when Reddit marketing was the one silver bullet to show up in ChatGPT responses? That changed overnight in August! Generative AI citations and best practices can and will change constantly, so be ready to test and pivot quickly when needed.
8. Measure campaign lift, not clicks or direct attribution.
I saw Rand Fishkin speak this summer at the Minneapolis Digital Summit and his entire keynote was about the death of clicks in marketing. As he pointed out, the way we all behave online — and how search engines serve up answers to queries — is so different that now organic traffic to websites has fallen dramatically. Instead, users follow a non-linear path of information gathering that often doesn’t lead to clicking through a Google search once. Attribution as we know it has radically changed.
Rand advised to instead measure campaign success by overall lift, rather than click-throughs or traditional conversion tracking. Did revenue increase over that time? Were sales calls more qualified when they got in touch? Did share of voice improve? How did your social media engagement stats behave?
This is yet another example of how PR and marketing teams need to work together from one playbook and refer to one scorecard. Learn how to tell the story of your brand’s performance together.
Unified teams with a unified strategy get your brand cited and seen
Earned media gets you cited. Paid reach gets you seen. Brandpoint helps you with both. We’ve spent 30 years helping brands share their message at scale, and we’ve evolved to help MarCom and PR professionals prepare stories for generative search, see where their brand shows up against competitors and know what to do next.


